The Tyranny of Positivity: Why Forced Optimism Harms the Grieving

Mallory J Greene
Mallory J Greene
June 14th 2024 - 4 minute read
Facebook Twitter Linkedin
When we experience loss, we encounter a well-meaning but destructive force: the cult of positivity. The constant pressure to "look on the bright side," or "move on" can invalidate our pain, isolate us in our grief, and hinder our healing process. It's time to dismantle this harmful mindset.

When we experience loss – whether the death of a loved one, the end of a relationship, or the shattering of a dream – we encounter a well-meaning but surprisingly destructive force: the cult of positivity. The constant pressure to "look on the bright side," "find the silver lining," or "move on" can invalidate our pain, isolate us in our grief, and ultimately hinder our healing process. It's time to dismantle this harmful mindset.

How Toxic Positivity Manifests

While usually cloaked in good intentions, here's how toxic positivity rears its head in the face of grief:

  • Cheerleading Cliches: Phrases like "everything happens for a reason," "they're in a better place now," or "time heals all wounds" dismiss the depth and complexity of grief. These platitudes, while meant to comfort, can feel dismissive of our raw pain.
  • Unsolicited Advice: People may bombard us with suggestions on how to "fix" our grief, implying that with enough effort, we can simply force ourselves into feeling better. This downplays the normal process of grieving, which takes time and doesn't follow a predictable schedule.
  • Focus on "Moving On": Society often pushes a narrative that equates healing with getting over our loss. This pressure to return to a pre-loss state can make us feel guilty or inadequate for harboring continued sadness.
  • Policing Emotions: Well-meaning friends and family might discourage the expression of "negative" emotions like anger, despair, or hopelessness. Yet, these are all natural and necessary parts of the grieving process.

The Harms of Enforced Cheerfulness

The cult of positivity doesn't make grief disappear; it simply buries it beneath a veneer of forced optimism. This has detrimental consequences:

  • Emotional Suppression: When we feel pressured to hide our true feelings, we deny ourselves a crucial avenue for processing loss. Suppressed grief can manifest in unhealthy ways like anxiety, depression, or physical ailments.
  • Isolation and Shame: The relentless message to "stay positive" can make grievers feel like their feelings are wrong or abnormal, leading to isolation and a sense of shame.
  • Delayed Healing: True healing isn't about bypassing difficult emotions but moving through them. When we deny ourselves the space to feel our sadness, anger, and all the complexities of grief, we prolong the process and hinder our ability to eventually find peace.

A Nuanced Approach to Support

Instead of toxic positivity, what helps someone who's grieving?

  • Validate, Don't Fix: Acknowledge their pain without trying to minimize it or offer solutions. Simple statements like "This must be so hard for you" or "I'm here to listen whenever you need" go a long way.
  • Embrace the Silence: Resist the urge to fill every moment with words. Your presence, even in moments of shared silence, conveys deep support.
  • Respect Individuality: Grief has no timeline or single "right" way to look. Avoid comparisons or judgments about how someone is processing their loss.
  • Practical Support: Offer tangible help to ease burdens. Prepare a meal, offer childcare, or help with errands. These actions demonstrate care without the pressure of forced emotional performance.

Why Shifting the Narrative Matters

Dismantling the cult of positivity is about more than just comfort – it impacts the long-term well-being of those who grieve. We need to foster a culture that understands:

  • Grief is Normal: Sadness, anger, and longing are natural responses to loss, not signs of weakness.
  • Healing Takes Time: There's no set deadline to "get over" grief. Everyone needs the space to process at their own pace.
  • Emotional Expression is Healthy: Giving ourselves permission to feel the full spectrum of our emotions is crucial to integrating a loss rather than suppressing it.

A Note to Those Grieving

If you're swimming against the tide of toxic positivity, remember:

  • You're Not Alone: Many people grapple with this unhelpful response to pain. Seek out those who understand the need for authentic grieving.
  • Your Feelings are Valid: Don't let anyone tell you how to feel or when to feel better. Honor your emotional journey.
  • Seek Supportive Spaces: Grief support groups or therapy can offer a haven where your pain is met with understanding and validation.

The Path to Authentic Support

By replacing toxic positivity with genuine empathy, we create a world where people feel supported to heal in a way that's authentic and transformative. It's time to redefine "support" – instead of demanding perky platitudes, let's offer open hearts, listening ears, and a respect for the profound and necessary work of grieving.

Here For You — Whenever You Need Us